Jeni’s has been a favorite of many for years. Whether you are looking for a classic scoop at the ice cream shop or a pint of the latest innovative flavors, Jeni’s has something for everyone. With a wide range of unique flavors, Jeni’s has become a popular choice for those looking to satisfy their sweet tooth.
With so many options, it can be hard to decide which flavor to try first. So, what are the best Jeni’s Ice Cream flavors?
What Are the Best Jeni’s Ice Cream Flavors?
There are so many amazing flavors to choose from at Jeni’s and it can be hard to narrow down your choices. To help make it easier, here are some of the best Jeni’s Ice Cream flavors:
Brown Butter Almond Brittle
This flavor is comparable to a classic flavor called butter pecan. You can describe it as being crunchy, smooth, sticky, and sweet. However, no matter what words you use to describe it, they will ultimately fall short.
Darkest Chocolate is exactly what it sounds like: a chocolate ice cream so dark that it barely qualifies as ice cream under the law. Rich, velvety chocolate that oozes down your tongue and leaves you fantasizing about it for days.
The seasonal Boozy Eggnog flavor from Jeni is spiked with Uncle Nearest whiskey, a small-batch Tennessee brand that we ranked among the best in the United States. The whiskey aroma is discernible upon opening the pint, but it is not overpowering.
Jeni’s Salty Caramel ice cream is superior to all other caramel-flavored ice creams. This pint of caramel ice cream, made by Jeni’s by caramelizing sugar in a kettle over the fire, has a rich nuttiness that other caramel ice creams lack.
Since 1996, this salted caramel ice cream has been Jeni’s signature flavor, and it’s easy to see why: it’s the ideal salted caramel ice cream.
Have you ever fantasized about berry cobbler ice cream? This ice cream is truly extraterrestrial, and we believe that everyone who visits Jeni’s should try it. This flavor is sweetened with jam made from blackberries and blackcurrants. While this jam is sweet, its tartness is the primary flavor ingredient.
This sour jam is blended with vanilla ice cream. And since the jam is so flavorful, plain vanilla is all that is required to fulfill all of your dessert desires.
Cold Brew With Coconut Cream
You wouldn’t anticipate a coffee ice cream to be so refreshing, but this one really delivers. Because it starts with Slingshot coffee, which has a light, crisp flavor. It is rich, but not so strong that you cannot enjoy it on a cold day. With this coffee, Jeni’s actually makes a cold brew sorbet.
However, this ice cream will not be as icy as you might anticipate from a sorbet. Because it is also blended with coconut cream. This coconut cream is also extremely light, making the entire dessert exceptionally refreshing. This flavor has a slight coconut flavor that distinguishes it from the Coffee with Cream and Sugar flavor .
Goat Cheese With Red Cherries
This ice cream is described as “scoopable cherry cheesecake” by Jeni’s. In fact, it is so delicious that you almost didn’t believe it was packaged in a carton. The Goat Cheese With Red Cherries is unquestionably the way to go if you’re looking for something completely unique and novel in your next ice cream experience.
Salted Peanut Butter With Chocolate Flecks
If you’re a fan of Reese’s, then Jeni’s Salted Peanut Butter with Chocolate Flecks ice cream is sure to be a treat. The salted and roasted ground peanuts are extremely salty, but they complement the extremely sweet base of this ice cream very well. The dark chocolate flecks add the perfect amount of bitterness and a delightful crunch that will leave you wanting more.
Sweet Cream Biscuits and Peach Jam
It is the peach jam that makes this flavor so appealing. It is pleasant and sweet, but not overly so. In fact, it tastes primarily like an exceptionally ripe and fresh peach. Because of their contrasting textures, the buttermilk ice cream and this jam pair perfectly. You’ve got both juiciness and creaminess, which is a match made in heaven.
Brandied Banana Brulee
This is one of the most innovative flavors the company has ever produced. The banana custard is made with brandy from a small batch (yes, there is actual brandy present). According to Jeni’s website, it is “made with real bananas, rather than a flavoring, because this is the only way to achieve the perfect, not too grassy, not too sweet banana flavor.”
Raspberry Rose Jelly Donut
The Raspberry Rose Donut is something you’ve never seen before. Who else would have thought to combine these ostensibly disparate flavors into a cohesive final product? The first component is vanilla custard. This custard is quite thick, making it the ideal rich base for otherwise delicate flavors. Then, the donut flakes are added.
However, the majority of the flavor comes from the raspberry-rose petal jam. The raspberry provides a hint of sweetness and much-needed tartness to balance the donut pieces, and the rose is delicately floral, so it does not overpower the other flavors.
Lemon and Blueberries Parfait
When it’s hot and humid outside, you may not be in the mood for the powerful flavors you would normally choose. When this occurs, a dessert such as the Lemon and Blueberries Parfait comes into play. This ice cream is exceptionally light and refreshing, which is not always the case with creamy ice creams.
This way, you don’t have to choose a sorbet simply because it’s too hot outside for a dessert like cookies and cream.
Skillet Cinnamon Roll
This is an excellent Jeni’s ice cream flavor if you’re craving something that tastes like a breakfast treat. It also features the renowned cream cheese ice cream, and we’re all for it. Then, cinnamon-scented brown sugar caramel and actual pastry flakes are added. These flakes are extraterrestrial, and they give the ice cream a texture that cannot be found in any other brand. Finally, they add additional cinnamon to the mixture.
There are so many delicious flavors to choose from at Jeni’s, and it can be hard to pick just one. The best way to decide which flavor to try is to consider what flavors you love most and read up on some of the unique flavors that Jeni’s offers. From Salty Caramel to Brambleberry Crisp, you will be sure to find something to satisfy your sweet tooth.