Fairlife Ice Cream Review

Indulging in a delicious scoop of ice cream is one of life’s simple pleasures. But what if you could have that creamy, dreamy goodness without any guilt? Enter Fairlife ice cream, a newcomer to the frozen aisle promising ultra-filtered, less sugar, and few calories pints. But does it live up to the hype? 

Join us as we take a closer look and give our honest review of Fairlife’s latest addition to the dessert scene.

What Are the Famous Flavors of Fairlife Ice Cream?

Cookies and Cream

Fairlife’s Cookies and Cream ice cream did not disappoint. As expected, it was a crowd-pleaser, with chocolatey and soft cookie pieces that were generously scattered throughout. The vanilla flavor was also delightful, but the texture was a tad on the icy side and could have been creamier and more melty. 

Nevertheless, given that Fairlife’s ice creams are marketed as being light, this shouldn’t come as a surprise. The Cookies and Cream flavor is worth trying for those who want to indulge in a tasty treat without feeling too guilty.

Double Fudge Brownie

Fairlife’s Double Fudge Brownie flavor is a decent ice cream choice, though it may not be the most amazing option out there. The chocolate ice cream itself was decent, tasting very much like their chocolate milk but frozen. The brownie pieces, on the other hand, were a pleasant surprise with their soft and pillowy texture similar to that of a Fiber One brownie. 

FAIR Nutrition Facts

However, the fudge swirl proved to be a bit of a disappointment, as it had a harsh, acidic canned chocolate syrup flavor that didn’t quite mesh well with the sweetness level of the ice cream. It might be better to stick to the brownie pieces and skip the fudge swirl in this flavor.

Chocolate and Vanilla

Fairlife’s Chocolate and Vanilla ice cream is a tasty option that is pretty good, despite being a little on the icy side. The vanilla flavor features delightful flecks of real vanilla bean, while the chocolate flavor is mild but still pleasant. It’s worth noting that with a higher fat content, the chocolate would have been even more luscious. 

However, it’s important to keep your expectations in check when it comes to this ice cream, as a serving of the vanilla flavor is roughly equivalent to a glass of 2% milk with a little added sugar. If you’re looking for a light and tasty frozen treat, Fairlife’s Chocolate and Vanilla ice cream is definitely worth a try.

Chocolate Peanut Butter

Unfortunately, Fairlife’s Chocolate Peanut Butter ice cream was a major letdown. Despite its name, there was no actual peanut butter to be found in the product, only added peanut flavoring. While the inclusion of real peanut butter might be difficult in a light ice cream, it begs the question of why this flavor was even created in the first place. 

The only mildly redeeming aspect of this flavor were the pieces of chocolate flakes, but overall it was a rough experience. If you’re a fan of chocolate and peanut butter, it might be better to look elsewhere for a more satisfying frozen treat.

Java Chip

Fairlife’s Java Chip ice cream is certainly lower in fat than other ice creams, but interestingly enough, this is not as noticeable in the coffee version. Despite this, the chocolate flakes found in this flavor are a definite highlight, much like in the peanut butter version. They are pleasant to eat and break down easily, without any waxy aftertaste. 

FAIR Butter flavor

Although this ice cream may have a slower melt than others, the coffee flavor is certainly worth trying if you’re a fan of the rich and robust taste of java. If you’re looking for a lower-fat frozen treat that still has plenty of flavor, Fairlife’s Java Chip ice cream is definitely worth giving a try.

Mint Chip

Fairlife’s Mint Chip ice cream is a classic choice that’s sure to please. The minty flavor is refreshing and adds a delightful twist to the usual chocolate chip combination. While a full-fat version of this flavor would likely melt better and have an even richer taste, Fairlife’s lighter version is still quite good. 

In fact, this ice cream would make a fantastic addition to an ice cream sandwich, with its smooth and creamy texture pairing perfectly with two soft cookies. If you’re looking for a light and refreshing frozen treat, Fairlife’s Mint Chip ice cream is definitely a great choice.

Is Fairlife Ice Cream Healthy?

Fairlife Ice Cream is a unique product that offers a delicious frozen treat with some added health benefits. Rich in protein and with fewer calories and less sugar than traditional ice cream, it’s a great option for those looking to indulge without going overboard. 

Whether you enjoy it in a float or use it as a base for your favorite pies, Fairlife Ice Cream is a versatile and satisfying choice. Additionally, with fewer calories than other ice creams, it’s a great way to indulge in a sweet treat without feeling guilty.


Fairlife Ice Cream offers a range of delicious and unique flavors that are perfect for those looking for a lighter, healthier option without sacrificing taste. While some flavors may not be as creamy as their full-fat counterparts, the added benefits of fewer calories and more protein make it a great choice for anyone looking to indulge in a sweet treat. 

With a variety of flavors to choose from and versatile usage, Fairlife Ice Cream is definitely worth trying.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts

Skip to content