With so many flavors to choose from, how do you decide which one is the absolute best Tillamook ice cream flavor? There’s no right or wrong answer here, as everyone’s tastes differ, but we’ve compiled a list of some of the most popular and unique flavors to help you decide. Here are some of the best Tillamook ice cream flavors to try.
What is the Best Tillamook Ice Cream Flavor?
Mudslide
Mudslide is the most popular Tillamook flavor. Beginning with chocolate, peanut, and salt-based ice cream, chocolate chips and melted fudge are added to the mixture. These ingredients create a rich, flavorful, and instantly satisfying dessert [1]. A few scoops of mudslide ice cream can satisfy a serious sugar craving.
Coffee Almond Fudge
If you like coffee as much as most people do, Tillamook’s Coffee Almond Fudge is the best thing ever. It has a strong, rich coffee flavor that goes well with the smooth fudge and crunchy almond pieces. The combination of agave syrup, cocoa, and cornstarch makes the texture smooth and creamy.
This ice cream is perfect for mornings when you need a little extra caffeine boost after your regular cup of coffee or just a little sweet pick-me-up to start the day.
Rocky Road
Rocky Road is an old and well-known flavor of ice cream. Tillamook’s version of this chocolate ice cream with marshmallows and nuts does not let you down. Rich chocolate flavor, and the marshmallows are just the right amount of fluffy. Almonds give the ice cream a nice crunch when they are added.
This flavor is great for chocolate lovers who don’t want something too heavy. A little bit of safflower oil is also on this Rocky Road. Some studies have shown that safflower oil may help with inflammation and have other benefits. Rocky Road is also a great choice for people who want a classic ice cream flavor with a Tillamook twist.
Chocolaty Chip Cookie Dough
Cookie dough is one of those flavors that is universally adored and always tastes delicious. Additionally, the cookie dough flavor has a comforting quality. Perhaps it reminds us of a time before we had to deal with the stresses of life when we were safe and secure at home. Tillamook has mastered the art of chocolate chip cookie dough regardless.
The dessert begins with cookie dough-flavored ice cream, which is combined with cookie dough balls and chocolate chunks.
Cookies and Cream
Tillamook’s version includes chocolate cream sandwich pieces interspersed with French vanilla ice cream. It is a delicious dessert for those who enjoy cookies and cream, and it is not overly sweet. The ice cream itself is noteworthy as well. French vanilla ice cream from Tillamook serves as the base of this confection. This vanilla ice cream from Tillamook is less complex than its other vanilla ice creams.
Chocolate Peanut Butter
The combination of peanut butter and chocolate. This is yet another classic pairing. This flavor of ice cream from Tillamook leaves nothing to chance, providing a truly decadent treat. It begins with delectable rich chocolate ice cream. A swirl of salted peanut butter complements the ice cream.
Because the dessert would otherwise be far too sweet, adding salt to the peanut butter is highly effective.
Marionberry Pie
Marionberry, if you’re unfamiliar, is an Oregon blackberry native to the Marion County region. It is not surprising that Tillamook has found a way to honor their home state, given that they are also from Oregon. As the name suggests, this is not your average fruit ice cream. It is intended to taste like Marionberry pie, complete with berries, pie crust, and vanilla ice cream.
Chocolate Chip
The chocolate chips in Chocolate Chip ice cream are big and not too sweet, which makes them a nice contrast to the vanilla base. If you can keep yourself from eating more than one bowl of chocolate chip ice cream in a day, you can eat this ice cream every day. Even though it might be fun once in a while, you won’t be going back to the freezer to get more.
You’ll probably like it, but it might not stand out as much as some of the other Tillamook flavors.
Oregon Dark Cherry
Here’s one more taste of fruit for you to think about. Oregon Dark Cherry ice cream is also made with bright, fresh fruit. The cherries work especially well because they have a rich flavor that is even better than what we talked about with peaches and raspberries. Even the taste of the ice cream is great.
The ice cream also has pieces of real Oregon cherries, which is pretty cool. This is important to point out because many recipes only use cherry puree and don’t use any cherry pieces at all. Real fruit is always better because it gives you a wider range of textures.
Caramel Butter Pecan
Even though this is not Tillamook’s most popular flavor, it is quickly becoming a favorite, especially among caramel fans. So, what should you hope for? Well, it starts with caramel ice cream that has a swirl of caramel and lots of butter pecans mixed in. This ice cream really stands out because of the caramel.
Even though there are many other butter pecan ice creams on the market, not many of them have this much caramel. The sweetness of the caramel and the nuttiness of the pecans make for an excellent contrast.
Monster Cookie
This flavor tastes like cookies and cream ice cream on steroids. It has almost every cookie mix-in you can think of, like M&Ms, peanut butter, chocolate chips, and oatmeal. The ice cream tastes a little bit like cookie dough and has a salted peanut butter swirl in it. It’s a great ice cream that tastes great and keeps people coming back for more.
But there is one big problem: the oats. It makes sense to put oats in a cookie, especially if the cookie has a lot of other things in it as well. But it seems strange to put them in ice cream. The oats don’t work as well as they could, and they get mushy very quickly.
Vanilla Bean
There are many different kinds of vanilla ice cream on the market. Tillamook has a few different kinds, like French Vanilla and Old-Fashioned Vanilla. But their Vanilla Bean is by far the best, and every time people rave about it. The ice cream is exactly what you’d expect: plain, creamy vanilla ice cream with flakes of crushed vanilla beans.
The vanilla beans make the ice cream taste even more like vanilla, which makes it much more interesting. The Vanilla Bean from Tillamook is so good that you can even eat it by itself. Or, you can serve it with any number of desserts, like warm apple pie.
Peaches and Cream
Tillamook’s Peaches and Cream is a star that doesn’t get enough attention. It’s a great choice for fruit lovers because the peaches are still juicy and taste like the real thing. But the treat is more than just ice cream and peach pieces. A swirl of peach sauce runs through the ice cream as well.
Aside from the peach pieces and peach swirl, the ice cream is pretty plain. Some people don’t think the ice cream is very good, while others think the subtle flavor is a great contrast. When you’re tired of ice cream with too many flavors, the creamy ice cream and sweet peaches are great.
White Chocolate Raspberry
The taste of white chocolate and raspberry is hard to beat. It works well because white chocolate is sweet and creamy, and raspberries are full of flavor. Tillamook makes their ice cream with real raspberry puree, which makes the berry flavor stand out. The white ice cream is also perfect, with a sweet, creamy flavor that is hard to miss.
Adding fresh raspberries on top of the ice cream would make it even more interesting. This ice cream is perfect if you want something fruity that isn’t too rich, like Peaches and Cream. Many of the other flavors of ice cream are based on chocolate, and they can get pretty strong.
Udderly Chocolate
This treat is for chocolate lovers, as the name suggests. It’s a mix of milk chocolate ice cream and white chocolate ice cream, with chocolate chunks of both flavors. Because of the way it’s made, you can be sure that every bite will be full of chocolate. Also, they use two kinds of chocolate ice cream. This version has a lot more different tastes than one that just has milk chocolate ice cream.
Conclusion
The best Tillamook ice cream flavor is ultimately up to personal preference. However, some of the most popular and unique flavors include Mudslide, Coffee Almond Fudge, Rocky Road, Chocolaty Chip Cookie Dough, Cookies and Cream, Chocolate Peanut Butter, Marionberry Pie, Chocolate Chip, Oregon Dark Cherry, Caramel Butter Pecan, Monster Cookie, Vanilla Bean, Peaches and Cream, White Chocolate Raspberry, and Udderly Chocolate.
While all of these flavors offer something special, the one you choose will ultimately depend on your own taste buds.