Milk Bar Ice Cream Review — Best Flavors and More

Looking for a sweet treat that will satisfy your cravings? Look no further than Milk Bar Ice Cream. Known for their playful flavors and unique twists on classic desserts, Milk Bar has become a go-to destination for ice cream lovers. 

We will explore some of their most popular flavors and share our thoughts on what makes this ice cream shop a must-visit for anyone with a sweet tooth.

What is the Company Behind Milk Bar Ice Cream?

Milk Bar is a bakery that takes pride in serving up nostalgic treats with unique and unexpected flavor combinations. Recently, they have ventured into the world of ice cream with their signature pints. Some of their most popular flavors include cereal milk, birthday cake, and gooey butter pie. 

These delectable treats are available for purchase through Milk Bar’s website as well as at grocery stores across the country. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic flavor or something more adventurous, Milk Bar’s ice cream pints are sure to satisfy your sweet tooth.

What Are the Famous Flavors of Milk Bar Ice Cream?

Peanut Butter Chocolate Cookie Crunch

MILK Choco Bday

Indulge in the decadent Peanut Butter Chocolate Cookie Crunch pint, made with a peanut butter chocolate ice cream base that is loaded with peanut butter cookie crumbs and fudgy chocolate cookie batter. What sets this pint apart is the use of crunchy and slightly salty peanut butter swirls, which add a new dimension to the texture and flavor of the desert. 

As you savor every bite, you’ll also be treated to a rich fudgy chocolate swirl that elevates the flavor profile of the pint. Despite the additional flavors, the peanut butter chocolate blend remains the star of this show.

Gingerbread House

For a seasonal treat that will transport you straight to the holiday season, try the Gingerbread House ice cream pint. This flavor is made with gingerbread ice cream, mixed with crunchy gingerbread cookie bits and candy gems. To top it off, the pint also features sweet icing swirls that complement the gingerbread flavor. 

While the gingerbread taste is noticeable, it takes a backseat to the sugary icing swirls. That being said, the gingerbread cookie crunch is a standout element of the pint, capturing the essence of the holiday season and making for a truly nostalgic experience.

Milk Bar Pie

Indulge in the rich and creamy Milk Bar Pie ice cream pint, featuring swirls of Milk Bar Pie filling that is similar to a chess pie, made with generous amounts of butter, sugar, and eggs. This pint is also infused with crushed toasted oat crust, all in a deep vanilla base that provides a comforting and classic taste. 

MILK Candy cane

What sets this flavor apart is the use of brown butter, which adds an additional layer of richness and depth to the pint. While this flavor is described as vanilla, the Milk Bar Pie filling and brown butter notes truly steal the show.

Birthday Cake

For a birthday celebration in a pint, try the Birthday Cake ice cream pint, inspired by Milk Bar’s beloved dessert of the same name. This flavor is made with a vanilla cake-flavored base, infused with chunks of cake, frosting, and sprinkles for a festive touch. 

As with all Milk Bar flavors, the birthday cake taste is designed to evoke the nostalgic flavor of from-a-box funfetti cake, and this pint does not disappoint. However, it’s worth noting that the flavor is more reminiscent of birthday cake rather than actual vanilla cake. 

With chunks of frosting mixed in, this pint provides a delightful surprise in every scoop.

Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow

For a classic ice cream experience with a twist, try the Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow pint. This flavor is a recognizable cookie dough ice cream, with the addition of melted marshmallows, chocolate-flavored chunks, and a satisfying cornflake crunch. The notes of browned butter and vanilla add depth and complexity to the flavor profile, making it reminiscent of the Milk Bar Pie pint. 

MILK Choco Mint

While you’ll definitely enjoy the cookie dough taste, identifying the melted marshmallow may prove to be a challenge, and the distribution of the cornflake crunch could be more even throughout the pint. This flavor is a great option for those who want a familiar taste with a unique twist.

Cereal Milk

For a taste of nostalgia in a pint, look no further than the Cereal Milk ice cream. This signature flavor from Milk Bar replicates the familiar taste of milk at the bottom of a bowl of Cornflakes. While the base of this ice cream is vanilla, it’s the infusion of corn flakes that sets it apart. 

The flavor profile is a perfect reminder of how carbohydrates break down into sugar molecules, as the cornmeal’s natural sweetness is enhanced with additional sugar. The Cornflakes crunch swirl, while not as crunchy as the version offered in Milk Bar locations, is still evenly distributed throughout the pint, providing a satisfying texture. 

Cereal Milk is a must-try for anyone looking for a unique and comforting ice cream flavor.

MILK Choco bday pint

Where Can You Buy a Milk Bar Ice Cream?

If you’re looking to stock up on Milk Bar’s delicious ice cream, you can purchase bulk packages on their website. These packages include two to four pints in a box, along with other treats. For those who want to get creative in the kitchen, Milk Bar also offers a make-your-own ice cream sandwich kit. 

If you only need a pint or two, you can find them at select retailers like Target, Whole Foods, and Amazon Fresh for $6 each.

Is Milk Bar Ice Cream Worth Trying?

Milk Bar’s unique and playful approach to dessert is on full display in their ice cream offerings. With signature flavors like Cereal Milk, Birthday Cake, and Peanut Butter Chocolate Cookie Crunch, there is something for everyone to enjoy. While some flavors may be hit or miss for individual taste preferences, the overall quality of the ice cream is top-notch. 

Plus, the option to purchase bulk packages or try out their make-your-own ice cream sandwich kit adds to the fun and versatility of the brand. So if you’re a fan of nostalgic flavors and unexpected combinations, Milk Bar’s ice cream is definitely worth a try.


Milk Bar Ice Cream is a delightful addition to their already beloved lineup of nostalgic desserts. With unique flavor combinations, high-quality ingredients, and versatile purchasing options, Milk Bar Ice Cream is definitely worth a try for anyone looking to indulge in some playful and delicious frozen treats.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts

Skip to content